CoSIDA Academic All-Americans
1986 Christopher Mack (2nd team)
1990 David Doyle (2nd)
1991 Sean Mullendore (2nd)
1992 Sean Mullendore (1st)
1996 Lance Sanders (2nd)
2001 Brant Haverdink (1st)
2009 Brandon Luczak (1st)
2009 Nate Kopydlowski (1st)
2017 David Vanderkloot (2nd)
2020 Noah Coplan (2nd)
NCAA Postgraduate Scholarship Recipients
1965 Tom Nicolai
MIAA Al Deal Scholar-Athlete Award
2009-10 Brandon Luczak (Football/Baseball)
All-Americans
1999 Jeff Dillingham, Kick Returner (USAfootball.com 3rd team)
1999 Eric Gerwin, Linebacker (USAfootball.com 4th team)
1999 Eric Gerwin, Linebacker (D3football.com honorable mention)
1999 Nick Lachapelle, Defensive Line (USAfootball.com honorable mention)
2000 Brant Haverdink, Linebacker (USAfootball.com 3rd team)
2001 Brant Haverdink, Linebacker (Hewlett Packard 3rd team)
2004 Jeremy Vanisacker, Linebacker (D3football.com 2nd team)
All-Region
2005 Jeff Green, Wide Receiver (D3football.com 3rd team)
2006 Chris Werme, Cornerback (D3football.com 2nd team)
2008 Shane Nolan, Kick Returner (D3football.com 3rd team)
2009 Jimmy Semelsberger, Wide Receiver (D3football.com 2nd team)
2013 Josh Wise, Wide Receiver (D3football.com 3rd team)
2015 Octavius Sanders, Cornerback (D3football.com 3rd team)
MIAA MVP's
1939 Dan Wood, B (Co-MVP)
1956 Bob Urschalitz, B
1999 Eric Gerwin, Defense
2001 Brant Haverdink, Defense
2004 Jeremy Vanisacker, Defense
USA Football All-Star Classic
1997 Lance Sanders
1997 Gregg McDonald
Aztec Bowl Participants
1999 Nick Lachapelle, Defensive Line
2001 Brant Haverdink, Linebacker
2004 Jeremy Vanisacker, Linebacker
Tazón de Estrellas (Bowl of the Stars)
2010 Cory McCain
2012 Dimeko Price
2012 Jimmy Frye
2013 Ryan Gregory
2013 Jake Larioza
2013 Josh Wise
2015 Octavius Sanders
2015 Dylan Zerki
2016 Sean Bauer
2016 BJ Smith
2017 Sai Klein
2017 Quentin Sweeney
Division III Football Senior Classic Participants
2009 Brandon Luczak, Quarterback
2009 Jimmy Semelsberger, Wide Receiver
2014 Alex Dietrich, Wide Receiver
2014 Connor Rzeznik, Linebacker
FCS Senior Scout Bowl Participants
2012 Erick Helfmann